中原企管評論

The Process of Reviewing

The submitted manuscript will be reviewed by the members of editorial board and scholars who have the related research background of the author(s).
The Editor-in-Chief will consider the fitness of the submitted manuscript and consult with the board members who specialize in the same field as the author to decide the reviewers.
Two selected reviewers will decide whether a manuscript is acceptable and have to make comments on the manuscript and to report one of the following five categories:
(1) Acceptance with no revision
(2) Acceptance with minor revision (manuscript will be returned to corresponding authors for minor revision, and the revised manuscript will be published without another further full process of review)
(3)Acceptance with minor revision (Further review required)
(4)Acceptance with major revision (Further review required)
(5)Rejection
Chart of remarks

Remarks		Viewpoints of the second reviewer
Remarks		Acceptance	Minor Revision without Further Review	Minor revision	Major revision	Unacceptable
Viewpoints of the first reviewer	Acceptance	Acceptance	Acceptance after revision	Revision	Revision	Reviewed by Assigned Third Reviewer
	Minor Revision without Further Review	Acceptance after revision	Acceptance after revision	Revision	Revision	Reviewed by Assigned Third Reviewer
	Minor revision	Revision	Revision	Revision	Revision	Reviewed by Assigned Third Reviewer
	Major revision	Revision	Revision	Revision	Revision	Rejection
	Unacceptable	Reviewed by Assigned Third Reviewer	Reviewed by Assigned Third Reviewer	Reviewed by Assigned Third Reviewer	Rejection	Rejection

Note:

1. If the third reviewer reports one of the following categories, the manuscript will be returned to corresponding authors for revision, and the resubmitted manuscript will be subjected to another further review process.
(1) Minor Revision without Further Review
(2) Minor revision
(3) Major revision
2. The manuscript will be rejected if If the third reviewer reports to “rejection”.

中原企管評論

The Process of Reviewing

The Process of Reviewing

Chung Yuan Christian University